Good bourbon is scarce these days with all these hipsters taking up the hobby. My favorites though, that are still readily available on the shelf, are:
- Knob Creek Single Barrel (Has some of the same complexity and flavor of Top shelf stuff. Excellent choice that still flies under the radar)
- Bookers ( from the Jim Beam fam. This was my 1st taste of 'good' whiskey.Uncut, unfiltered. Meaning not watered down. Sometimes you get a bottle where you can still see some of the sediment swirling around the bottle, not diluted to a certain 'proof'. The buttery way it coats your mouth... just MMM)
- Bakers ( much like Bookers, same heritage)
All of the above are part of the Jim Beam fam.
- WL Weller 12 year (If you can find it, is excellent bang for the buck. Dont get it confused with WL Weller Special Reserve)
- Wild Turkey Rare Breed ( Theres also one called Forgiven. The regular Wild Turkey is a bit burly, even for me, but these are pretty good)
- E.H. Taylor Small batch Barrel Proof(bit more rare) (Love them Both. From Buffalo Trace Distillaries, the guys that produce stuff like George T. Stagg and carry on the Pappy van winkle line. I have a bottle of the single barrel, but have yet to crack it open)
- Buffalo Trace (Im a fan of Buffalo Trace distillery. I think they make excellent products starting with this one. Its a good starter and cheap enough to have around and not get mad when someone mixes it.)
- Elijah Craig 12 yr ( I carry this one for when people visit and want to try, but i know will feel compelled to mix it with coke or something, still pretty good.)
-Old Grandad 114 ( A favorite amongst the old timer bourbon drinkers. There was a time when there was a rumor circulating that there was a shortage of this, and for a brief period, it became hard to find. I think the same would happen to Knob Creek Single Barrel if word go out)
-Four Roses (4 roses has a cult following. Initially, not impressed. But the last Small Batch i tried was very good, better than the Single Barrel. In some ABCs you'll see a bottle that looks like the Single Barrel, but says Barrel Proof. Those are excellent, especially the ones that have a label that says "Hand Selected for ....*whatever liquor store*...". There are like 8 Different mashbills/'flavors'. So look at the little tag to see what you might like. Im not a fan of the 'Minty' or 'Fruity' flavors. But some are.)
The 'Pappy' line is good because its smooth but a bit overrated, in my opinion. The lure of it is the heritage, but finding it is wishful thinking. I would never dream of buying one at the rate theyre going for now (Pappy 15 yr ~$700). George T. Stagg is much more complex, probably the best I've had. The exception being Pappy 20/23yr. For the age, they are silky smooth.
I keep my bar stocked with all of these. I also have some really top shelf/more rare varieties. But i always tell people, you cant start too high otherwise you wont be able to taste the increase in quality/ appreciate it.
One thing i see a lot is people going for Basil Hayden or Woodford Reserve because the bottle looks "pretty". I havent had either in a while. I remember them being ALRIGHT, but nothing memorable.
One other thing: I drink my bourbon Neat. Occasionally, if its a new bottle and still 'hot' (high alcohol), then ill add a few drops of water or an ice cube. As time goes by and the excess alcohol evaporates, the flavor profile will become bolder and it wont burn so much..but the heat is half the fun of bourbon. If thats too much for you, then maybe a spiked lemonade with fruit and an umbrella suit you better. ;)
I always tell newbs: If youre afraid to drink it, it'll burn. Dont put it back like a shot. Dont take a teeny little sip. That makes it burn. Take a decent sip, let it linger and coat your mouth ( i always close my eyes and rock my head side to side so it rolls over my tongue) then let it go down. That way, it wont burn, but youll feel the heat set in nicely..
Not in the biz, just a drinker/collector. Ironically, Im not even that much of a drinker... Just developed a taste and appreciation over time.