Perhaps the discussion is pointless inasmuch as srans is concerned. (perhaps not, time will tell) It is a good discussion to have, nevertheless.
I don't think anybody here believes that it was a good idea for srans to leave. I think people came to his defense based on the tight bonds that they built with srans here. The message might have gotten a bit lost in the discussion on whether people were being disrespectful to srans or not.
There is a simple, consistent method to quit here: Post Roll, Honor That Promise, Repeat. Drifting or leaving the site are completely incompatible with this method. Anything we do or say that diminishes or confuses our method is harmful to the site, and more importantly, the quitters in it. Srans mind might be made up, but what about the guy with 150 days under his belt thinking about drifting and happens upon this intro? How is he served by us soft pedaling the truth because we happen to like quitter "x"?
There is a truth to defend, and by God, we should defend it.
Post roll, honor your promise, repeat.
anything that takes away from that message weakens our effectiveness.